Transforming "Maybe Later" into "Yes, Please!" – The $169M Genius Trick from Wikipedia!

Cimi Ganjolla

2 min read

Most websites have a "Maybe Later" button, but let’s be honest: most of them are broken. They simply close the popup and miss the chance to engage the user.

But Wikipedia? They’ve turned “Maybe Later” into a $169M goldmine. Here’s how.

When you click "Maybe Later" on their donation popup, instead of closing the conversation, they ask for your email to remind you later. And guess what? It works like magic! 🧠✨

This simple tweak turned casual “Maybe Later” clicks into a powerful fundraising tool.

💡 The Big Idea

Add an email capture step after every “Maybe Later” click on your website. Then, follow up with smart, timely reminders.

It’s such a small change, but it’s nothing short of BRILLIANT.

🎯 Why It Works

It’s all about a little psychological magic called the Consistency Effect:

🧠 When someone clicks “Maybe Later” (instead of “No”), they’re mentally committing to consider your offer.
💌 Asking for their email feels natural because they already hinted at interest.
💸 When reminded, they’re more likely to follow through because they’ve already said “Maybe.”

⚡️ How to Apply This Game-Changer in 5 Minutes

Here’s a simple 3-step formula you can implement today:

📝 1. Add an Email Catcher

Update your popups for:

Homepage offers
Trial-ending notices
Upgrade prompts
Limited-time deals
Exit-intent popups

Use this copy: "Want us to remind you later about upgrading? Drop your email below!"

🤖 2. Automate a Smart Reminder Sequence

24 hours later: Send a friendly reminder.
A week later: Highlight the benefits they’re missing.
Final nudge: Offer a limited-time incentive to seal the deal.

💃 3. Make Saying “Yes” Easy

Keep the reminder emails simple.
Ask for just one action (e.g., “Click here to upgrade”).
Remind them they already showed interest – it’s a gentle nudge, not a hard sell.

⏳ 4. Test and Optimize the Timing

Experiment with sending reminders at different intervals.

Too soon? They might feel pressured.
Too late? They may have forgotten you. Find the sweet spot that keeps them engaged.

🔑 Key Takeaway

Don’t let “Maybe Later” be the end of the conversation. Turn it into an opportunity! A simple email capture after that click can transform hesitant users into happy customers.

Wikipedia proved it works - now it’s your turn to leverage this genius strategy.

🔔 Follow for More: Don't miss out on future articles packed with practical tips and inspiring ideas.